Tuesday, 21 November 1882

Who is writing to me, I ask you? The architect! Whatever has come over the poor dear. And at the same time, Julian's reply to my letter from Russia — which was forwarded in my absence and sent on to Nice.
Now, since yesterday I have been working at the studio, returned to the utmost simplicity — concerning myself neither with the choice of model, nor with its beauty, nor with any pretension. Six months of this regime and you will do whatever you wish. He is convinced that for three years I have been doing nothing, and I shall end by believing it myself.
In reality, since I have been painting, things are not going well — does that mean I am doing less? No: I have put in dreadful effort, and for two years I have been attempting things that are perhaps too difficult, but I work. Julian, however, insists that it must be because I do not work, that I scatter myself... They all bore me; I bore myself... I shall never be cured. Can you not feel what is so horrible, so unjust, so despairing in that? I bear the thought with calm — I was prepared for it — but even now it is not that; it is that I cannot believe it is for ever.
Do you understand? For one's entire life, until death. It will clearly affect my character and my mind — to say nothing of the fact that it has already given me grey hairs. I repeat: I still do not believe it. It is impossible that there is nothing, nothing to be done; that it is for eternity; that I shall die with this veil between the universe and myself, and that never, never, never...
Is it not true that one cannot believe in a verdict so definitive, so irrevocable? And not the shadow of hope — not the shadow, not the shadow.
It makes me so anxious while I work — I am always afraid the model speaks without my hearing it, or someone at the studio, or that people laugh... Or else they will speak too loudly for me.
And with the model at home...
But good Lord — one tells them plainly that... That what? That I am deaf?!! Just try it! Such an admission of infirmity! And an infirmity so humiliating, so stupid, so sad — an infirmity! I have not the courage for it; always the hope that no one will notice.
You know, I try to make sentences here but I don't believe it... It seems to me that I am speaking of someone else... And how to make real this horrible nightmare, this dreadful, cruel, atrocious thing — in the full bloom of youth, in the midst of life! How to believe that it is possible, that it is not a bad dream, that it is eternal?
I do sculpture in the evenings at home.
Mme Cartwright came with her daughter. The architect had told me I must not call on her, and we had decided to throw her overboard — and here she arrived today, embraced me, and then... thirty-six thousand civilities, sympathies, cordialities... I started it all, after all, by wanting her invited to our soirée and then going to call on her... What an idiot I am — to know artists and have Breslau's connections... As if that conferred talent. Breslau said stupid and vile things about me that she used to repeat before she knew me, and now she sings hymns of admiration... To everyone who knows me and comes to report it... This evening the flattery is so adroit that I will let myself be taken in... She begins by saying that if I worked for money she would commission her daughter's portrait, etc., etc. I answer that I shall do it with pleasure, from the heart. And she adds that it would be so, so agreeable to her, that she would be so delighted, so pleased — and this for the Salon; for besides the pleasure of having a pretty portrait, it is also a small spite she wishes to do to someone... (Do you feel the subtlety?) Something she has been contemplating...
To set me against Breslau and prove to her that she was wrong to quarrel with her.
[Words blacked out: It is not difficult to] guess. If that is what she thinks, she exaggerates my merits, alas! As for the desire to strike at Breslau — I have no doubt of it, and the rod is well chosen; for if I succeed, she will smart for it as I smart when she triumphs. I no longer have any prestige at the studio; people think me finished; Julian will have said I no longer work... That is what is maddening — when I do everything in the world. I shall truly end by believing it. Mlle Cartwright (pronounce: Cartrayt) resembles her mother, who is magnificent, but heavier... Less graceful... The mother, with her dark hair and her clouded blue eyes of a bacchante, is superb. She must be at least thirty-six and looks only twenty-five — no rouge, no artifice. In the evening with her neck bare, she is a splendour: full, rich forms, a magnificent complexion, and the bearing of a ship that has spread all its sails. The daughter is simple, honest, a little lumpen, and with a thickish oval... Rather wooden... If she genuinely trusted that I could annoy Breslau, she would ask for her own portrait — which Breslau was to paint when they quarrelled. Ah! if in two months I could produce studies so good, so good, so good that Julian might inspire her with that confidence... Come now — God surely owes me this consolation... Especially as I have not the slightest desire to be spiteful: Breslau would not even be diminished by it; there is room for more than one success under the sun; she would not die of it, and I should live by it. She would fume, certainly — but that would be the effect of her bad nature and would not even give me pleasure. God can see clearly that those mean and base satisfactions that consist in enjoying the jealousy of others do not touch me. Come — that is noble, that is fine, that is rare. Does it merit nothing? People say this often enough — but to think it... The heavens may render me blind, lame, bald and hunchbacked, and I shall think no less that I am better, more honest, more generous, greater than many — than nearly everyone — and that it is unjust, cruel and barbarous to make me unhappy.

Notes

The architect: Emile Bastien, brother of painter Jules Bastien-Lepage, who worked as an architect. Marie's tone — "the poor dear" — suggests fond condescension rather than romantic interest.
Mme Cartwright: an English or Anglo-American woman in Parisian artistic circles, friend of Louise Breslau. Her manoeuvre — offering to commission a portrait from Marie as a way of wounding Breslau — is a masterpiece of social strategy that Marie sees through perfectly.
A bacchante: in classical mythology, a female devotee of Bacchus, associated with wild beauty. By the 1880s the term had a specific painterly connotation — the type of magnificent, unrestrained feminine beauty that appeared in academic Salon paintings.