Friday, 22 September 1882

Yesterday I brought the fisherman to Tony — it is not bad, but that is all; he finds it [Crossed out: original,] very well composed, the expression of the face very good, well handled on canvas. But it is thin in paint, the edges are dry, the fellow is not bathed in air; these observations are Tony's and mine — I knew it. Then I speak of my progress, my work, and involuntarily make the error of expressing my discouragement, the little confidence I inspire in myself... I posed today and that imbecile tells me he has spoken with Julian about me — about my attempts, my ambitions.
In short I moved him to pity yesterday, and together with Julian he decided I would do well to make simple studio studies — that the difficulties of open-air painting are beyond my present strength and that it discourages me. He says this with such consideration that I have great difficulty not weeping. I believe he thinks I am in despair at having failed with the old man, on whose success Julian had allowed me to hope, and he wants to spare me what he imagines to be despairs.
He has always told me that no one progresses more quickly, that I am doing very well — and he laughed a great deal at my desire to go faster than nature. Only yesterday — that I am admirably gifted, that I need only continue — and now I have spoiled everything by my mad complaints of yesterday and my dismayed bearing today; I shall no longer believe in encouragements, for I have shown myself too unhappy for it not to be pity.
And then... In short, the blow has fallen: open-air painting discourages me with its difficulties. I need simple studio studies, they said. So my painting... I have not even dared speak of it; it is as though the air turned to lead and dragged the skin of my face toward the ground, and fire in my arms...
Since I complain, since I have had the foolishness to reveal the scale of my ambitions, these two men can only give me reasonable advice — seeing that it is for me neither a game nor a pastime... and that I am in despair over it. So like two honest physicians they prescribe the drastic remedy.
From all this it appears I am not in a state to paint a figure... A picture — for a studio study always passes muster whereas... I should not have let it show that I had placed wild hopes on the old fisherman... I shall no longer have the truth from them, and then... Breslau.
Breslau is two and a half years ahead of me. What does that prove? Nothing — for two years ago she was stronger than I am today, and even three years ago. She has been painting for six and a half years, and I for exactly four. I am not counting drawing — neither for her nor for me.
So if by 1884 I have not done what she did last year, I am her inferior. I have no need to wait for that to know it.
It will soon be five years that I have been working. And it is a year that I have been suffering martyrdom. Cruel sufferings, I assure you — losing the good opinion one had of oneself, losing confidence, courage, hope. Working only with the horrible conviction that it leads nowhere. And that paralyses. And nothing can restore me — save a good canvas... And that is impossible in this moral disaster...
Since I admit myself that Breslau is two and a half years ahead...
Yes — I dreamed of overtaking her in spite of that... Although it is difficult to be more gifted than she...
Prodigies and phenomena are rare — one says there are scarcely any. In short, all I ask is to equal her; so it is 1881 when she triumphed — I have until 1884... for in 1881 she had been painting five years and three months, [Crossed out: whereas by then] I will have been painting five years and nine months. (I always take the month of May, on account of the Salon.)
In the end, there is only one thing to consider: that I was unable to paint my old man very well — that I had the good fortune to lay my hands on an original, interesting, artistic subject, and could do nothing with it. That is the monster.
My eyes have just fallen on the canvas of the painting... I am without strength — everything is finished — an annihilation of the entire being... And not even the rhetoric to express this consternation that takes from me the physical strength to hold the pen... Now for excuses: it rained and I was always interrupted in the middle of executing a section — that is true... I should not have presented this canvas, which I did not yet consider presentable, but it rained and I wanted advice, being unable to work. Then, seeing this impotence, he says that open air is too difficult for me... And tomorrow I return to the Grande Jatte, and with the energy, the fury of despair, I shall begin again.
Yesterday we dined at Viroflay at the Marquise de Lambertye's. Carolus was expected but the weather was so bad that we had no one.
And who was imposed upon — it is always poor me. Mme de Lambertye is that Charonnet widow, ten times a millionairess, who married the Marquis five years ago. But on the very day of the marriage the husband departed for his château, which he had had redeemed, telling his wife: "My dear friend, we have married our capitals and not our hearts." All in all it is not very ignoble — for after all he gave her the title she wanted, and she redeemed the properties and provided the means to maintain them... Giving and taking. And the gentleman's calculation is rather sound, since the lady is in no position to dishonour her husband, given her ugliness, her bulk, and her common manner. But she apparently dreamed of a real husband, and her old mother complains to anyone who will listen that the Marquis declined to fulfil his conjugal duties toward her hippopotamus of a daughter. There are at least 18 stone in her hippo [sic].